Someone sent me this article recently which I had not seen before.
It was originally published on MentalHealth.com and I found it to be generally informative though by nature of it being very broad to cover all cults, I think there are some things in here that are not so applicable to scientology. I have left a few comments in red italics throughout.
How being in a cult can affect your mental health
What is a cult?
According to the International Cultic Studies Association (ICSA), a cult is “an ideological organization held together by charismatic relations and demanding total commitment.”
Within this definition, we see the basis of cult psychology – it demands total commitment from its members. We also see some of the characteristic signs of a cult. Also, cults are based on a specific ideology led by someone charismatic and require you to put the organization first and yourself second.
Part of this process is what’s known as social influence. Cults have particular norms that all members must obey. These norms might dictate what you can or cannot do (e.g., you can’t leave the cult’s property), what you believe (e.g., that the cult leader is somehow exceptional), and who you have contact with (e.g., you might be forbidden from speaking to your family).
These and other norms are necessary for maintaining order within the cult. They also help create a group identity and a strong “us versus them” outlook that facilitates obedience among cult members to the cult’s cause and leader.
Everything said here is 100% true for scientology.
How are people convinced to join cults?
Before discussing how people are convinced to join a cult, it’s essential to consider factors that make someone more likely to be convinced to join in the first place.
A top risk factor for someone to join a cult is exposure to cultic behavior at some point in their earlier life. Whether that’s an extreme situation like being raised in a cult, a more low-level interaction like being aware that a cult’s compound is nearby, or something in between, exposure to cults increases the likelihood of joining a cult later in life by more than 32 percent.
This figure may be true, but I have never observed this myself — other than the fact that scientology has been most successful in California where “cults” have had a more prominent presence than anywhere else I am familiar with.
One of the risk factors for joining a cult is when individuals are searching for something or missing something important. This ‘something’ could be a sense of belonging, a connection to a higher power, or something in between. However, most people join cults to address some affective or social issue occurring in their lives.
I would add to this in scientology — the promise of the ability to help others. This is a big factor for many who come into scientology. It offers the “tools” to help friends, family or anyone.
Another factor researchers have noted for people who join cults is that these individuals tend to have psychiatric difficulties, especially within the year before joining. Anxiety disorders are the most common issue, with nearly 52 percent of former cult members reporting having an anxiety disorder. Mood disorders (45.2 percent) and substance abuse disorders (12.9 percent) are also common among cult members.
I think the substance abuse disorders is probably a higher percentage in scientology due to the focus on Narconon/Purif as a route into scientology. I don’t really think the other two factors are as important when it comes to scientology which takes a somewhat different approach than other cults.
Given the vulnerabilities of people that join cults, it is often relatively easy to employ cult psychology techniques to convince people to join. As noted earlier, some of the perceived benefits of a cult by prospective members is a sense of belonging and purpose. Furthermore, prospective members might gain a sense of safety and appreciate cult life’s structure.
When people are anxious, sad, abusing drugs, or all of the above, the promise of a hot meal, a comfortable bed, and a supportive network of like-minded people is highly alluring. In other words, cult leaders often don’t have to work that hard to convince people to join – even the promise of basic life essentials can usually do the trick.
This last paragraph is not the technique used by scientology.
What techniques are used to keep people in cults?
One of the most common ways cults retain their members is through gaslighting. This type of psychological manipulation makes you question reality, including the validity of your own perceptions, sensations, thoughts, and memories. In fact, gaslighting can be so severe that you begin to question your very sanity.
Cult leaders employ gaslighting and other mind-control techniques to maintain control over their followers. After all, if you question the validity of your memory and point of view, you’re more likely to believe what the cult leader is telling you to be true.
One only need watch one of the scientology events or propaganda videos or read their press releases to know how true this is. ALL information about scientology can ONLY come from scientology. If Hubbard (and now Miscavige) doesn’t say it, it is not true, and if they do, it is.
Isolation is another key method for keeping people in cults and is one of the main signs of a cult as well. Cults are usually isolated from the outside world (e.g., having a compound in the middle of nowhere), and cult members are often cut off from the outside world, including family, friends, and other associates from their previous lives.
This is definitely true for Sea Org members. Scientologists in general are cut off from the outside world because they believe the media are merchants of chaos and there is a grand conspiracy by the psychs to destroy them. So they ignore information that doesn’t match what they want to hear. They tend to associate with other scientologists who reinforce their views.
Some of this article seems to address cults that exist in a single compound (Branch Davidians, Jonestown etc) which is not scientology.
This isolationism creates a greater and greater level of control exerted by the cult and cult leader. For example, you might first be asked to tithe part of your income to the cult. Then you might be asked to move near the cult compound and then onto the cult property. Eventually, you might entirely rely on the cult organization for necessities and services.
Many cults also use what’s called “love bombing” to draw people in and keep them under the cult’s control. As noted earlier, many people that join cults have anxiety or mood disorders and abuse drugs. These activities are often associated with low self-esteem and feelings of worthlessness.
Love bombing preys on those feelings by showering new members with praise. The constant stream of flattery, compliments, and other affirmations can be intoxicating to someone that has a negative self-concept. Even if alarm bells go off that the situation is inappropriate, unhealthy, or even dangerous, the constant love bombs often prove too powerful and keep people thoroughly ensconced in the cult environment.
Long-term effects of being in a cult
The effects of being in a cult might be examined through two lenses: the effects of growing up in a cult and the psychological effects of leaving a cult.
The effects of growing up in a cult can be long-lasting and severe. Children in cults are often subjected to serious restrictions (e.g., no outside contact with other children) that can lead to difficulties with intimacy, low self-esteem, and the development of mental disorders. Furthermore, the restrictive nature of their upbringing can cause children in cults to develop identity confusion, panic attacks, and anxiety disorders when that restrictive structure is no longer there.
There are many other effects of growing up in a cult:
- Feelings of guilt and shame
- Distrust of others
- Development of phobias
- Depression
- Post-traumatic stress disorder
Untreated, these issues can cause further difficulties for children who formerly lived in a cult. Seeking appropriate psychological treatment is paramount for addressing these and other effects of cult psychology.
The other component of this is the psychological effects of leaving a cult. As just noted, children raised in cults face many potential psychological issues during and after their cult experience. The same goes for adults that choose to leave.
For example, former cult members can feel incredibly isolated and out of sorts and unable to navigate the basics of independent life. Moreover, these practical issues can lead to anxiety, depression, and even dissociative episodes.
Additionally, former cult members face psychological challenges because of the realization that their former belief system was not what they thought it to be. They may see themselves as lost, damaged, or helpless. They might also question other aspects of their lives, such as whether they are worthy of others’ love.
Periods of mourning can be experienced by former cult members, too. The loss of friends and a sense of community can be especially painful, as can the difficulties of reintegrating with society and family members. This is to say nothing of issues like finding a job, a place to live, and getting appropriate mental health care, difficulties with which can exacerbate existing psychological problems.
This whole section is very applicable to scientology.
How to leave a cult
Leaving a cult is no easy task. However, there are some basic steps you can take that make your escape more likely:
- Identify people on the outside that can help you. If possible, try to contact these people to arrange for them to help you escape.
- Identify opportunities when you can escape. Trips outside the cult compound are likely the most accessible to affect your escape.
- Pack what necessities you can. If your escape is prolonged, clothing, food, water, and other essentials are needed.
- Seek shelter with friends or family, a homeless shelter, or the police, who can put you in protective custody if you feel you’re in danger.
- Cut all ties with the cult and its members. Breaking contact with the cult will make it much easier not to get sucked back in.
- Seek psychological help. As discussed earlier, there are serious psychological effects of leaving a cult. You will need support from loved ones and professional assistance to work through the psychological damage you’ve experienced.
Some good tips here!
This is exactly why we created the Aftermath Foundation.
Suzie Lovell says
Excellent article brigs alot of attention to things that go along with cults. The mental health aspects of cults all add up to being dangerous for the person. Leaving those aspects of mental health is hard to do in a high control group/ cult situation.but once you see the traits you can’t ignore them.
Denny Owen says
My recent post on cults may be of interest, “From Narcissistic Abusers to Global Movements: The Deceptive Spectrum of Cults.”
Just my one-man effort to help shed a little light on those dark corners of society with the hope to prevent further harm and protect vulnerable individuals from exploitation.
https://tinyurl.com/bdfy6yf5
Chris Shugart says
a cult is “an ideological organization held together by charismatic relations and demanding total commitment.”
Thank you for that clear and concise definition. I’ve always had a problem with the word “cult” because it became a misused, overused catch-all buzz word meant to criticize any organization one doesn’t like. That’s just being intellectually lazy.
Imogen says
Alot of great points mentioned in this article. I found it nice in particular the How to get out of a cult portion brings up so many ways that someone in a cult can do to get out and get help.
The mental health aspect of leaving a cult has always been interesting to me I feel as ot would be a straining experience leaving a situation like that especially if you where raised in it.
pluvo says
The best and most comprehensive and comprehensible issue of “What is a Cult?”, I’ve ever encountered is from Mark Vicente (video and text, so one can also read comfortable while listening):
https://www.markvicente.com/thoughts/2023/5/15/what-is-a-cult
Imogen says
Mark’s video is absolutely incredible. he just seems like a great guy in general who wants to warn people about the danger of cults through his own experience. Lots of insight and wisdom that he has shared after leaving NXIVM.
AnEx says
pluvo. Nice article – thanks. If you don’t know already, you may like this podcast with Mark and Mike:
https://www.mikerindersblog.org/podcast-with-mark-vicente-of-the-vow/
Eviee says
Cults and mental health don’t particularly seem to mix well within the cult mindset. Most cults that i have looked into dont seem to believe in anything mental health related. Leaving a cult seems difficult but this article helps especially at the end with the list of how to leave a cult.
LoosingMyReligion says
In many, if not most, cases, the level of indoctrination one has been subjected to is the key issue. How much this has permeated the way of thinking and reasoning, in the conscious and unconscious, is unfortunately decisive.
Just think, as far as scn is concerned, just the idea of being critical about it or leaving is automatically a symptom of “overts and withholds” for the person himself. Getting out of it often is an ordeal and if it was the Sea Org it’s even worse.
What has worked for me is thinking about what it would be like next and holding on to that thought.
Tori James Art says
This was a fantastic article. Your input wad also very insightful and informative. Cults and information about mental health don’t go well together. Because the mental health information never matches up with the information the the cult has given its followers.
Ammo Alamo says
Sadly, there is little chance most Scientologists will read this information, certainly not from its original website of mentalhealth dot com. What Scilon would get caught looking at mental health information – that’s where the Psyches hang out. Yikes!
But oddly enough, posting “How Being in a Cult Can Affect Your Mental Health” here on Mike’s blog actually increases the chance that some few Scientologists will read it.
How’s that for irony?
otherles says
Back in the seventies (in my teen years) I met a recruiter for the Unification Church at the Nicollet Avenue entrance of the downtown Minneapolis Public Library. I told her I was an atheist and she went away.